Your Guide to the Best Butter for Perfect Buttercream Every Time

Butter is the soul of buttercream, shaping its texture, flavour, and overall quality. If you’re part of any baking community, chances are you’ve seen the question, “What is the best butter for buttercream?” countless times. And for good reason! Choosing the right butter can elevate your buttercream from good to absolutely indulgent.

Here’s my guide to help you understand what makes some butter better than others and how to achieve silky, luxurious buttercream every time.

The Importance of Butterfat Content

The first thing to consider when choosing butter for buttercream is its butterfat content. Butterfat matters because it affects the richness of flavour and the consistency of your buttercream. For the best results, look for butter with a butterfat content of no less than 82%.

Butter with a higher butterfat percentage has less water, which means a smoother, creamier buttercream that’s less likely to split. Many store-brand butters are around 80% butterfat (this is applicable to the USA), which might seem like a small difference, but the extra water can impact your buttercream’s texture and stability. This is especially important if you’re working in warm conditions or making advanced designs like intricate piping. High-butterfat options lead to better structure and taste.

Pistachio & Strawberry Cake: I used cultured butter for this particular buttercream

What to Look for When Buying Butter

While butterfat content is crucial, other factors can also affect the quality of your buttercream. Here’s a breakdown of what to look for:

1. Grass-Fed Butter

Grass-fed butter is made from the milk of cows that graze on grass, which gives the butter a rich, golden colour and a fuller flavour profile. This type of butter has a naturally fresh taste and tends to be higher in nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids. It’s an excellent choice for buttercream if you want to add depth of flavour.

2. Organic Butter

Organic butter is produced without synthetic pesticides, hormones, or antibiotics, making it a popular option for those who value clean and sustainable ingredients. Organic butter can also have a purer, more vibrant flavour than conventionally produced butters.

3. Cultured Butter

Cultured butter is made with fermented cream, giving it a slightly tangy flavour that adds complexity to your buttercream. The subtle tang balances the sweetness in traditional buttercream recipes, resulting in a beautifully nuanced taste.

The Role of Flavour Profiles

The type of butter you use can dramatically affect your buttercream’s flavour. High-quality butters, especially grass-fed or cultured options, have a natural, buttery richness. These nuances can shine in a simple buttercream but may interfere if you’re looking for a very neutral base to carry other flavours, like chocolate or fruit.

If you need an ultra-neutral flavour, aim for unsalted butter with minimal additional processing. Salted butter, albeit tempting for some bakers, can alter the sweetness and stability of buttercream, so always opt for unsalted to remain in control of the flavour.

Italian Meringue Buttercream: no white colour has been added to achieve the white.

How to Achieve White Buttercream

One common challenge bakers face is achieving a perfectly white buttercream. Butter naturally has a yellowish hue, particularly grass-fed varieties. While this is desirable for many baked goods, you might need a snow-white buttercream for wedding cakes or other designs.

Here are some tips for creating white buttercream:

1. Use Light-Coloured Butter
   If achieving a bright white buttercream is crucial, opt for lighter-coloured brands of butter. Ultra-processed butters often have a paler appearance, though you may sacrifice a bit of flavour depth.
2. Add White Food Colouring
   Many bakers use white food colouring to counteract butter’s yellow tint. However, this comes with a caveat. Many white food colourings contain titanium dioxide, an ingredient that has been banned in the EU due to health concerns. Consider your local regulations and personal preferences when deciding whether to use this method.
3. Whip the Butter Longer
   Whipping your butter for several minutes before incorporating sugar can help lighten its colour naturally. The air whipped into the butter creates a fluffier texture and a slightly lighter colour.

Tips and Tricks for Perfect Buttercream

Baking buttercream can be an art and a science. Here are practical tips to ensure success no matter where in the world you’re baking:

•  Room Temperature Is Key
  Ensure your butter is softened but not melted. Too cold, and it’s hard to whip; too soft, and it can cause the buttercream to become runny.
•  Use High-Quality Ingredients Across the Board
  Good butter isn’t the only important factor; use quality powdered sugar and vanilla extract to enhance the flavour profile of your buttercream.
•  Be Patient While Mixing
  Buttercream improves with time and patience. Whip it thoroughly to achieve a smooth and fluffy texture, and always scrape down the sides of your bowl to ensure even mixing.

Buttercream That Works for All

Whether you’re in the UK, USA, or anywhere else in the world, the principles of selecting high-quality butter remain the same. Grass-fed, organic, cultured, or simply a butter with over 82% butterfat content will elevate your buttercream to new heights.

For bakers looking for a snow-white buttercream, white food colouring might be your go-to, but remember the regulations and health concerns surrounding titanium dioxide. Wherever possible, experiment with long whipping times to lighten the butter naturally.

At its core, buttercream is all about balancing flavour, technique, and aesthetics. With these tips in mind, you can create a buttercream that’s not only delicious but also professional-grade in texture and design.

Happy baking!

Loved this post? Sign up for my newsletter to receive exclusive recipes, expert baking tips, and inspiration straight to your inbox! Plus, get a free recipe for my Almond, Lemon & Blueberry Cake as a welcome gift. Join my baking community below.