Your Guide to the Best Butter for Perfect Buttercream Every Time

The Best Butter for Buttercream: How to Choose & Make Silky Smooth Frosting

Butter is the soul of buttercream, shaping its texture, flavour, and overall quality. If you’re part of any baking community, chances are you’ve seen the question, “What is the best butter for buttercream?” countless times. And for good reason! Choosing the right butter can elevate your buttercream from good to absolutely indulgent.

In this guide, you’ll learn what makes some butters better for buttercream, how to choose the right one, and professional techniques to achieve silky smooth buttercream frosting every time.

The Importance of Butterfat Content

The first thing to consider when choosing butter for buttercream is its butterfat content. This is crucial because it affects flavour, consistency, and stability. For the best results, look for butter with a butterfat content of at least 82%.

✅ Higher butterfat butter (82% or more) contains less water, resulting in a creamier, more stable buttercream that’s less likely to split.
✅ Many store-brand butters (especially in the USA) contain only 80% butterfat, adding excess moisture that can make buttercream grainy or unstable.
✅ European-style butters tend to have higher butterfat content, making them an excellent choice for buttercream.

If you’re wondering what butter is best for buttercream frosting, opt for grass-fed or European-style butter for better texture, richer flavour, and improved stability—especially in warm conditions.

A beautifully piped Lambeth-style cake featuring intricate vintage-inspired decorations, made with silky Italian meringue buttercream,
naturally coloured for an all-natural finish. Perfect for elegant celebrations and classic cake artistry.

What to Look for When Buying Butter

While butterfat content is crucial, other factors affect buttercream texture and flavour. Here’s what to consider:

1. Grass-Fed Butter

🐄 Made from cows that graze on fresh grass, this butter has a rich golden colour and fuller flavour profile. It contains higher levels of omega-3s and vitamins, making it a great choice for buttercream that has depth of flavour.

2. Organic Butter

🌿 Produced without synthetic pesticides, hormones, or antibiotics, organic butter is a great option for those who value clean, high-quality ingredients. It often has a purer flavour, enhancing the overall taste of buttercream.

3. Cultured Butter

🥄 This butter is made with fermented cream, giving it a slightly tangy flavour that can balance the sweetness of traditional buttercream. If you love a buttercream with a nuanced, complex taste, cultured butter is a fantastic choice.

The Role of Flavour Profiles

The type of butter you use will directly affect the flavour of your buttercream. High-quality butters, especially grass-fed or cultured options, have a natural, buttery richness. These nuances shine in a simple buttercream but may interfere if you want a neutral base to carry other flavours like chocolate or fruit.

✅ If you want a buttercream with a pure, buttery taste, opt for grass-fed or cultured butter.
✅ If you need an ultra-neutral buttercream, use unsalted, minimally processed butter to ensure the flavour doesn’t overpower other ingredients.
✅ Avoid salted butter, as it can alter the sweetness and stability of your frosting.

🎂 Want to master buttercream techniques? Learn how to create silky, stable, and flavourful buttercream in The Ultimate Guide to Cake Fillings & Frostings—your complete resource for mastering textures and techniques.

A delicate mini loaf cake adorned with hand-piped buttercream flowers, showcasing the artistry of Italian meringue buttercream.
The white IMBC remains uncoloured, highlighting its natural hue and silky texture for an elegant, all-natural finish.

How to Achieve White Buttercream

Many bakers struggle with achieving pure white buttercream frosting because butter naturally has a yellow hue. If you need wedding cake-white buttercream, here are some solutions:

✅ Use Light-Coloured Butter – Some ultra-processed butters have a paler colour, though you may sacrifice some flavour.
✅ Whip the Butter Longer – Whipping butter for a few extra minutes incorporates air, naturally lightening the colour.
✅ Add a Tiny Amount of Violet Gel Food Colouring – A drop of violet neutralises yellow tones, creating a whiter effect.

🎂 Want the smoothest buttercream every time? The Ultimate Guide to Cake Fillings & Frostings covers everything you need to create flawless frostings and fillings.

Pro Tips for Perfect Buttercream

Baking buttercream is both an art and a science. Use these expert tips for flawless results:

✅ Room Temperature is Key – Soften butter, but don’t let it melt! Too cold, and it won’t whip; too soft, and it will be runny.
✅ Use High-Quality Ingredients – Great butter is essential, but also use good-quality and vanilla extract for enhanced flavour.
✅ Be Patient While Mixing –  Whip it thoroughly and scrape down the bowl to ensure even mixing.

Buttercream That Works for All Bakers

No matter where you are in the world, the principles of choosing high-quality butter for buttercream remain the same.

✔️ Grass-fed, organic, and cultured butter can elevate your buttercream’s flavour.
✔️ Choosing a butter with over 82% butterfat will improve stability, texture, and piping results.
✔️ For whiter buttercream, try whipping longer or using a touch of violet food colouring.

Buttercream is all about balancing flavour, technique, and aesthetics. With these expert tips, you’ll create a buttercream that’s silky smooth, stable, and delicious every time.

🎂 Want more expert guidance? Learn the secrets to perfect buttercream, ganache, and more in The Ultimate Guide to Cake Fillings & Frostings!

Happy baking!

Loved this post? Sign up for my newsletter to receive exclusive recipes, expert baking tips, and inspiration straight to your inbox! Join my baking community below.