Afternoon Tea vs High Tea: What’s the Difference?

When you hear the phrase “afternoon tea,” you probably picture delicate finger sandwiches, scones with clotted cream, and a cup of Earl Grey served in fine china. But what about “high tea”? Many people mistakenly use the two terms interchangeably, yet these quintessentially British traditions are quite distinct. Today, we’ll explore the differences between afternoon tea and high tea, their fascinating history, and their evolution in modern tea culture.

The Origins of Afternoon Tea

Afternoon tea, often seen as the epitome of British refinement, actually started as a practical solution in the 1840s. Anna, the Duchess of Bedford, is credited with beginning this tradition. At the time, the upper class typically ate two meals a day—breakfast and a late dinner around 8 or 9 p.m. Feeling hungry during the long wait between meals, Anna started ordering tea and light snacks to her room around 4 p.m.

The ritual quickly evolved into a social event, with friends joining Anna for tea. This new tradition became a status symbol for high society, complete with fine china, elegant teas, finger foods, and lighthearted conversation. Before long, afternoon tea was a celebrated custom in Britain, synonymous with luxury and leisure.

The Birth of High Tea

High tea, on the other hand, originated during the Industrial Revolution and had a very different purpose. This tradition began in working-class households as a hearty meal served in the early evening after a hard day’s work. Unlike afternoon tea, high tea wasn’t about leisure or elegance—it was about sustenance.

The term "high tea" comes from it being served at a proper dining table (or “high” table), as opposed to the low, casual tables associated with afternoon tea. High tea typically included robust dishes like meat pies, cold cuts, bread, butter, cheese, boiled eggs, and plenty of strong tea. It was practical, filling, and essential for labourers and their families.

Key Differences Between Afternoon Tea and High Tea

To clarify their differences, here’s a breakdown of timing, menus, and cultural significance:

1. Timing

• Afternoon Tea: Served around 3-5 p.m., primarily as a light refreshment.
• High Tea: Taken later, around 5-7 p.m., as a substantial evening meal.

2. Food Served

• Afternoon Tea:
  • Dainty finger sandwiches (cucumber, smoked salmon, etc.).
  • Scones with clotted cream and jam. Try my favourite scone recipe here.
  • Bite-sized pastries and cakes.
• High Tea:
  • Hearty dishes like shepherd’s pie, cold meats, baked beans, or roasted vegetables.
  • Bread, butter, or a heavier dessert like pudding or fruitcake.

3. Cultural Significance

• Afternoon Tea is often associated with wealth, leisure, and tradition. It’s an indulgent event, commonly offered in upscale tearooms or luxury hotels today.
• High Tea, by contrast, reflected the practical needs of working-class families. While less common nowadays, it still evokes nostalgia for comforting meals shared with loved ones.

The Evolution of These Traditions

Both afternoon and high tea have adapted to modern preferences:

• Afternoon Tea has become a luxurious treat, often enjoyed on special occasions. Many prestigious hotels, like The Ritz London, elevate the experience with champagne and elaborate menus.
• High Tea, though less practiced today, is remembered fondly as a wholesome, comforting meal. In parts of Northern England and Scotland, people still use the term to describe their evening meals, despite these meals no longer centring around tea.

Fun Fact About British Tea Traditions

Did you know Queen Victoria played a key role in popularising afternoon tea? Her fondness for tea and sponge cake elevated the ritual’s status, resulting in the classic "Victoria Sponge" we enjoy today.

Celebrate These Traditions for Yourself

Interested in experiencing these distinct customs? Here’s how you can enjoy each:

• Afternoon Tea:
  • Visit a traditional tearoom or prepare your own at home with scones, finger sandwiches, and fine china.
• High Tea:
  • Host a cozy meal with rustic dishes like pies, cheeses, and freshly baked bread.

Whether you’re drawn to the elegance of afternoon tea or the hearty comfort of high tea, both traditions highlight Britain’s enduring love for tea and the way it brings people together.

Now, the real question is—cream or jam first on your scone?

Stay tuned for my next blog post, where I’ll be sharing a selection of delicious afternoon tea recipes to get you inspired. Just a taste of what’s to come in this delightful series—you won’t want to miss it!

Loved this post? Sign up for my newsletter to receive exclusive recipes, expert baking tips, and inspiration straight to your inbox! Plus, get a free recipe for my Almond, Lemon & Blueberry Cake as a welcome gift. Join my baking community below.